Uncertainty in Online Experiments with Dependent Data: An Evaluation of Bootstrap Methods

ACM Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD)


Many online experiments exhibit dependence between users and items. For example, in online advertising, observations that have a user or an ad in common are likely to be associated. Because of this, even in experiments involving millions of subjects, the difference in mean outcomes between control and treatment conditions can have substantial variance. Previous theoretical and simulation results demonstrate that not accounting for this kind of dependence structure can result in confidence intervals that are too narrow, leading to inaccurate hypothesis tests.

We develop a framework for understanding how dependence affects uncertainty in user-item experiments and evaluate how bootstrap methods that account for differing levels of dependence perform in practice. We use three real datasets describing user behaviors on Facebook – user responses to ads, search results, and News Feed stories – to generate data for synthetic experiments in which there is no effect of the treatment on average by design. We then estimate empirical Type I error rates for each bootstrap method. Accounting for dependence within a single type of unit (i.e., within-user dependence) is often sufficient to get reasonable error rates. But when experiments have effects, as one might expect in the field, accounting for multiple units with a multiway bootstrap can be necessary to get close to the advertised Type I error rates. This work provides guidance to practitioners evaluating large-scale experiments, and highlights the importance of analysis of inferential methods for dependence structures common to online systems.

Related Publications

All Publications

Federated Learning for User Privacy and Data Confidentiality Workshop At ICML - July 24, 2021

Federated Learning with Buffered Asynchronous Aggregation

John Nguyen, Kshitiz Malik, Hongyuan Zhan, Ashkan Yousefpour, Michael Rabbat, Mani Malek, Dzmitry Huba

UAI - July 28, 2021

A Nonmyopic Approach to Cost-Constrained Bayesian Optimization

Eric Hans Lee, David Eriksson, Valerio Perrone, Matthias Seeger

ACM MM - October 20, 2021

EVRNet: Efficient Video Restoration on Edge Devices

Sachin Mehta, Amit Kumar, Fitsum Reda, Varun Nasery, Vikram Mulukutla, Rakesh Ranjan, Vikas Chandra

ICCV - October 11, 2021

Egocentric Pose Estimation from Human Vision Span

Hao Jiang, Vamsi Krishna Ithapu

To help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience, we use cookies. By clicking or navigating the site, you agree to allow our collection of information on and off Facebook through cookies. Learn more, including about available controls: Cookies Policy