On the Pitfalls of Measuring Emergent Communication



How do we know if communication is emerging in a multi-agent system? The vast majority of recent papers on emergent communication show that adding a communication channel leads to an increase in reward or task success. This is a useful indicator, but provides only a coarse measure of the agent’s learned communication abilities. As we move towards more complex environments, it becomes imperative to have a set of finer tools that allow qualitative and quantitative insights into the emergence of communication. This may be especially useful to allow humans to monitor agents’ behaviour, whether for fault detection, assessing performance, or even building trust. In this paper, we examine a few intuitive existing metrics for measuring communication, and show that they can be misleading. Specifically, by training deep reinforcement learning agents to play simple matrix games augmented with a communication channel, we find a scenario where agents appear to communicate (their messages provide information about their subsequent action), and yet the messages do not impact the environment or other agent in any way. We explain this phenomenon using ablation studies and by visualizing the representations of the learned policies. We also survey some commonly used metrics for measuring emergent communication, and provide recommendations as to when these metrics should be used.

Related Publications

All Publications

Interspeech - October 12, 2021

LiRA: Learning Visual Speech Representations from Audio through Self-supervision

Pingchuan Ma, Rodrigo Mira, Stavros Petridis, Björn W. Schuller, Maja Pantic

ICML - July 18, 2021

Latency-Aware Neural Architecture Search with Multi-Objective Bayesian Optimization

David Eriksson, Pierce I-Jen Chuang, Samuel Daulton, Peng Xia, Akshat Shrivastava, Arun Babu, Shicong Zhao, Ahmed Aly, Ganesh Venkatesh, Maximilian Balandat

IEEE Transactions on Image Processing Journal - March 9, 2021

Inspirational Adversarial Image Generation

Baptiste Rozière, Morgane Rivière, Olivier Teytaud, Jérémy Rapin, Yann LeCun, Camille Couprie

ICML - July 12, 2020

Lookahead-Bounded Q-Learning

Ibrahim El Shar, Daniel Jiang

To help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience, we use cookies. By clicking or navigating the site, you agree to allow our collection of information on and off Facebook through cookies. Learn more, including about available controls: Cookies Policy