Multiplicative Pacing Equilibria in Auction Markets

Operations Research Journal


Budgets play a significant role in real-world sequential auction markets such as those implemented by internet companies. To maximize the value provided to auction participants, spending is smoothed across auctions so budgets are used for the best opportunities. Motivated by a mechanism used in practice by several companies, this paper considers a smoothing procedure that relies on pacing multipliers: on behalf of each buyer, the auction market applies a factor between 0 and 1 that uniformly scales the bids across all auctions. Reinterpreting this process as a game between buyers, we introduce the notion of pacing equilibrium, and prove that they are always guaranteed to exist. We demonstrate through examples that a market can have multiple pacing equilibria with large variations in several natural objectives. We show that pacing equilibria refine another popular solution concept, competitive equilibria, and show further connections between the two solution concepts. Although we show that computing either a social-welfare-maximizing or a revenue-maximizing pacing equilibrium is NP-hard, we present a mixed-integer program (MIP) that can be used to find equilibria optimizing several relevant objectives. We use the MIP to provide evidence that: (1) equilibrium multiplicity occurs very rarely across several families of random instances, (2) static MIP solutions can be used to improve the outcomes achieved by a dynamic pacing algorithm with instances based on a real-world auction market, and (3) for the instances we study, buyers do not have an incentive to misreport bids or budgets provided there are enough participants in the auction.

Related Publications

All Publications

CVPR - June 18, 2021

NeuroMorph: Unsupervised Shape Interpolation and Correspondence in One Go

Marvin Eisenberger, David Novotny, Gael Kerchenbaum, Patrick Labatut, Natalia Neverova, Daniel Cremers, Andrea Vedaldi

CVPR - June 18, 2021

Discovering Relationships between Object Categories via Universal Canonical Maps

Natalia Neverova, Artsiom Sanakoyeu, Patrick Labatut, David Novotny, Andrea Vedaldi

CVPR - June 17, 2021

Connecting What to Say With Where to Look by Modeling Human Attention Traces

Zihang Meng, Licheng Yu, Ning Zhang, Tamara Berg, Babak Damavandi, Vikas Singh, Amy Bearman

DSN - June 21, 2021

Near-Realtime Server Reboot Monitoring and Root Cause Analysis in a Large-Scale System

Fred Lin, Bhargav Bolla, Eric Pinkham, Neil Kodner, Daniel Moore, Amol Desai, Sriram Sankar

To help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience, we use cookies. By clicking or navigating the site, you agree to allow our collection of information on and off Facebook through cookies. Learn more, including about available controls: Cookies Policy